« 深入淺出王力宏 | Main | 喜欢王力宏的101条理由 »
August 02, 2005
陶喆 王力宏 周杰倫之全方位比較
Author: Unknown
日期: 2005年08月02日
來源： 搜狐娛樂MUSIC.SOHU.COM
陶喆：亞洲的R&B教父，音樂較有思想性，詞曲創作和演繹功底很到位。
1）人氣：不及力宏與杰倫，歌迷群比較小眾，一般是有一定文化底蘊與情調的小資，唱片銷量永遠不會太高。
2）創作：為藝術獻身，拒絕一切商業化。完美主義者，出道十年，只出5張專輯（含一張精選），典型慢工出細活，兩三年磨一劍，專輯品質一般有保障；歌詞依舊憤青，專輯《太平盛世》諷刺台灣虛華盛世，當政粉飾太平。專輯中《鬼》表現尤為明顯。另陶喆的業內評價與力宏旗鼓相當，均要高過杰倫。
3）代表作：《今天不回家》、《沙灘》、《I’m OK》、《月亮代表誰的心》、《黑色柳丁》、《飛機場的10：30》、《MELODY》、《SUSAN說》
4）唱功：陶喆的音域寬廣，現場功力另人咋舌，聽他唱歌你會感覺到力量和靈魂。真假音切換自然流暢，且有些高音也到了匪夷所思的地步，素有假音之王的稱號。
5）發展趨勢：穩步發展。
王力宏：華語樂壇R&B天王，音色是最有特色的，聲線磁性具有張力，詞曲創作和演繹堪稱一絕。音樂更具人性化與本土化，獨家命名製造chinked-out華語風情。
1） 人氣：執著做音樂，拒絕一切與音樂無關的宣傳。歌迷群最廣，下至小學生，上至小學生的父母。
2）創作：每三年兩張專輯，對創作歌手來講還能保質保量，實屬難能可貴。詞曲創作更貼近本土化（雖然生長在國外，但他心中的中華情是三個中最熾熱的），演繹風格多樣，爵士、搖滾、R&B、HIP-HOP、Rap全方位展示天才能力，自己溶入音樂同時，也帶給人們快樂。難能可貴的是，其創作的 chinked-out是一種全方位立體化的中西交融的民族風，是一種大音樂使命下更高境界的民族風，是與世界攜手的民族風。對西北采風中獲得的大量素材作了非常精心的取捨，並針對作品的意境進行了精心的編排，因而在作品中運用起來絲毫不留痕跡，十分精當。民族器樂十分和諧地烘托了作品的意境，恰到好處，堪稱絕妙。《心中的日月》古箏和笛聲穿插其中，更顯東方神韻。《竹林深處》悠揚的西藏女聲、中國鼓、長笛和HIP-HOP節拍如影隨形，更像是純正的中國音樂借鑒了HIP-HOP的現代節奏形式。
3）代表作：《情敵貝多芬》、《安全感》、《愛的就是你》、《唯一》、《龍的傳人》、《兩個人不等於我們》、《WHY》、《愛你等於愛自己》、《公轉自轉》、《讓我取暖》、《謝絕推銷你的愛》、《心中的日月》、《竹林深處》、《在那遙遠的地方》、《一首簡單的歌》、《星座》
4）唱功：聲線張馳自如，不僅演繹R&B得天獨厚，演繹其他厚實的作品最具優勢，比如爵士、搖滾、或激情或濃郁或古典意味的唯美情歌。
5）發展趨勢：從《心中的日月》可以展望“力宏一小步，樂壇一大步”時代的到來。
周杰倫：華語樂壇R&B獨特立行鼻祖,作曲天馬行空，行雲流水，商業第一，藝術第二，最具商業化與心計的R&B男歌手。
1） 人氣：《JAY》、《范特西》以一種勢如破竹的氣勢衝擊歌壇，唱歌沒調，口齒不清，似乎成了他的招牌，他的音樂成全了一類叛逆者，得到全中國N多15-25歲青少年的青睞。《葉惠美》、〈外婆〉（《七里香》），讓周天王的娘家人著時火了一把，在加上與其他女人（Vivian、Landy、Jolin）扯不清道不明的男女問題上了，虛熱人氣已達到頂峰。而他的音樂在臺灣金曲獎已經三年顆粒未收。如今，侯主播又成為周天王新聞的主角，之間分合所產生的媒體效應也是公司想要的，有心計的周天王已經開始游離於音樂之外，專靠更換女人來積攢人氣了。《頭文字D》中被外人（指不是周天王歌迷的廣大朋友們）指責根本沒有演技、毀了電影也只能說明他“影歌”兩栖的希望落空。而主題曲《飄移》更是顯出了他音樂上的疲態，“得飄、得飄、得意的飄”和《得意的笑》沒有音似也有形似了吧。同時，在music radio港臺榜單上兩周都沒有爬到前5的位置也可以看出周天王人氣的下滑。
對JAY系統瞭解一翻後，不禁要問他，你的人氣是怎麼得來的？
2）創作：一年一張的專輯速度夾雜著太多時間男女關係扯不清道不明的關係，專輯越來越不保質量，越來越商業化，比較經典的第一張以及驚世駭俗的第二張之後專輯質量呈抛物線趨勢一路下滑，這其中商業化的影響不可忽略。可悲，被商業化熏黑的天才。天馬行空，靈動俊逸的JAY已不復存在，取而代之的是一味地華而不實甚至賣弄做作的JAY。
3）代表作：《東風破》、《簡單愛》、《蝸牛》、《困獸之鬥》、《以父之名》、《遊園會》、《開不了口》、《星晴》、《最後的戰役》、《雙截棍》、《葉惠美》、《外婆》、《七里香》、《止戰之殤》、《我的地盤》
4）唱功：現場演唱忘詞跑調的情況屢見不鮮，音域狹窄唱破幾個音也是常事，甚至在聽他現場演唱飆音的時候都會替他捏把冷汗，吐字不清仍是杰倫的老毛病，甚至已經成為標誌，總之，杰倫真該好好加強唱功。也可能在他看來，炒作帶來的虛熱的人氣最重要，7月9日中國首場演唱會（北京演唱會）網友罵聲一片已不重要。
5） 發展趨勢：華語樂壇繼謝霆峰之後的又一位仲永。這也正是黃安在某本書預測的，05年下半年後會出現的。
Posted by staff at August 2, 2005 10:15 AM
Comments
I agree. I think out of everyone Leehom is the truest to his music. Although I used to like Jay Chou, I'm growing extremely annoyed by his lack of concentration to music. I think he's being way to attracted by commercial materialism. But after all these years Leehom is still the music loving college boy who first entered the music scene 10 years ago. Keep up the excellent work :)
Posted by: Sarah at August 15, 2005 12:04 PM
I agree with Sarah. Leehom's so passionate with his world of music. This precious spirit is rarely abtained by most musicians.
And Leehom's abundant energy and never-failing enthusiasm inspire me a lot.
:)
Posted by: Yoyo at August 29, 2005 01:28 PM
力宏為梁靜茹製作的"絲路"真的超好聽的 令我更期待力宏的新專輯喔!! 還有年底的演唱會!! 力宏加油!! ^_^
Posted by: kuan-fei at September 5, 2005 09:58 AM
已经可以听到：丝路了么？
内地还没有阿。
好想听呢！
Posted by: Yoyo at September 6, 2005 01:18 PM
Erm...I am a Malay fan of Lee Hom...so as you can see, i cant understand what is being stated above...can anyone be kind enough to translate it?
Posted by: Diyana Nazurah at September 7, 2005 01:50 PM
Hi! Diyana. :)
yes, certainly, with pleasure.
we are talking about the New song, Leehom wrote for 梁静茹Jasmine Liang, Silu （丝路).
I dont know how to translate it into English.
kuan-fei said she just listened this song, very good. But I have not got the chance to listen, as the mainland doesn't have it.
May I'm understood.
:)
Posted by: Yoyo at September 8, 2005 01:14 PM
All of you guys are so pathetic! I am a Boalt Hall Law School graduate, and my smart Chinese friends and I love Jay Chao not because he is "commercial," but his music has more "depth" and more "meaning" than the other two you talked about. David Tao's music has more "production value," because he spent tons of money in studio to perfect the sound. That is a good thing, but compared to Jay Chao, whose music sound more like demo (deliberately) and whose lyrics have tons more depth. David Tao's music is exactly the "same" kind of production value like other big record labels from the West, such as "Toto" and Michael Jackson. well you guys have no idea because you guys are stupid.
There are world renowned "classical music" critics who have said that Jay's music have achieved certain level of depths that other Asian classical musicians have never achieved.
Well, you guys have never heard of this classical music critic, because your logic and jealous grapes are so pathetic. Wake up and smell the coffee.
Posted by: Ken at November 13, 2005 02:19 PM
I have listened to Jay and Leehom's music and I must say I prefer Leehom's - but that's totally my own personal choice.
What I really admire about Leehom is the aim of his music-making, his high level of focus in achieving / or attaining this goal and his willingness to learn more about Chinese music even at this stage of his career. And the outputs from constant learning are very very impressive. Adding more - he's humble about the whole thing ("The more you know, the more you know you don't know").
I heard the demo for Leehom's "Come 'n get it" - It's a super hot track - well done! I'm really looking forward to his new album.
He talked about producing an English album at some stage - I reckon it'll be a good tool for promoting Chinese music to the western world (I know there are people from Europe who listen to his music now even if they can't understand a word of it! - I'm so happy for him.)
Cheers,
Cynny (NZ/HK)
Posted by: Cynthia at November 15, 2005 06:32 AM
我喜歡力宏....跟陶喆.....至於周董.....我絕得還好ㄟ...不知道為啥那ㄇ多人喜歡周董?真素ㄉ....力宏長得帥..歌又唱得好.又會很多樂器..很有才華...陶喆長得也不錯..歌也唱ㄉ好..又會寫歌.. 英文也很Good I'm love it
Posted by: Angela.ru at November 17, 2005 07:20 PM
已经习惯了别人把他们三个做比较,
可说实话,我不怎么喜欢这样的比较,更何况他们三个音乐风格各有不同,让人怎么去比较呢???
Posted by: Heney at December 8, 2005 01:38 PM
2005再壓軸~蓋世英雄~首波主打:花田錯
真的超好聽的!! 唱到心坎裡的感動!!~~~^_^
Posted by: kuan-fei at December 13, 2005 09:44 PM
First time poster! YAY ME!
I have to give you a HUGE round of applause. BRAVO! Very well written.
To Jay Chou fans:
I have to admit that he's got brilliant lyrics to match his not so "melodious" songs. But note this... he's not the one who wrote most of it...HAHAHA... pathetic? Nah. No one's pathetic larr. Just some of us (Music School Graduate) can't help wondering why people like him so much? As for Lee Hom's lyrics... well, if you really wanna compare both of them, I should say Jay's fans should be very much ashame of themselves if they do so (compare both of them). C'mon, Jay's totally chinese educated and Lee Hom's not. Yet he actually still manages to write his own lyrics.
As for darling David, I have nothing to say... because I do feel that he's music does its own talking. Don't get it wrong, I'm a number one fan of Lee Hom... But I do feel that David's songs has more well... "maturity"??
Posted by: JiaYing at December 17, 2005 11:15 PM
mmm interesting views ppl, but i reckon david has the best voice, and seem like a perfectionist, then lee hom, as for jay.... some good songs, but not so much related to his talent, rather his luck
Posted by: win710 at December 22, 2005 01:11 AM
看此篇時,還以為有什麼高見,誰知......,不值一哂
看他將周杰倫踩得一文不值已經知了吧.....
Posted by: 忠 at December 30, 2005 05:59 PM
Wow Ken, you are way too obsessed with proving your own genius and shoving your opinions down others' throats. Notice that everyone here has just been stating their own opinions without being insulting? Law school graduate and 'smart' Chinese friends indeed.
I personally think David Tao's music is really soulful and touches you if you're in a situation that's related to his lyrics. However.. I've cried at Lee Hom's Wei Yi, so I'd actually say David and Lee Hom on par in terms of emotions.
David's talent shines through, though Lee Hom does get a little 'too' innovative for me sometimes. =P I get a bit wierded out at some of his songs. But hey, change is good, Lee Hom's songs are very different.
As for Jay... I used to really, really, really love him. Seeing an album by Jay was enough for me, who cared what the songs were, I'd buy it cause it's Jay's! However... I feel that he's been imitating Western styles more and more lately, especially in his last two albums, and thus losing his own voice. Oh well, personal opinions. =)
Posted by: Mel at January 10, 2006 09:47 PM
WOOOOOOOTWOOOOOOOOT wangleehom rawks !! i LOVE him !! XDXD WOOTWOOT
Posted by: Gloriia at February 1, 2006 02:01 PM
I like both Leehom Wang,David Tao on the side of coziness with my ears.For Jay,I felt his albumns have keeping declining since his second albumn in point of quality.And he is getting more and more roistering.It's not easy to invite Jay to perform.And he's self-centered.Although their personalities differed,they are good friends.
is an excellent one,I think what ever might be on the same tiptop level are \ and this .I have to say,as acoustics,what their music gives us are totally different.Turn on your stereo,play Jay's R&B for half an hour,say,about 10watts,90dbs,how many guys could bear it?All the songs gives us the machine-made feelings. In contrary to Jay's,Leehom's are afford for thought.I reccomend Leehom's\\\\\\\\...
Posted by: steve kiang at February 7, 2006 02:53 PM
i'm writting this in office, so, not much time for me to write loads of words... juz want to say: after many years of listening to this 3 artist songs, i means seriously listen to & try to study their music along the way from their 1st album until now. what i can say is (my opinion) :
David Tao
=========
- the best
- most talented
- best vocal
- his song is very long lasting (i stiil always listen to his songs which are written on 1993, launch in first album on 1997)
- not commercial(emphasized on quality instead of popularity)
- meaningful songs
- he is the one who bring r&b, hip hop, jazz & some other special genre of music into chinese music industry. no david tao, no jay chow.
Lee Hom
=======
- nice vocal(sexy)
- handsome
- nice quality of songs
- also very talented
- he cant avoid popularity coz his face had oredi guaranteed popularity; but still glad that he still put some effort on quality.
- song not long lasting.
Jay
===
- i like his song very much; but that is until his 2nd album
- obviously cant sing
- some of his song is still really great; esspecially when u not listening to the vocal.
- very talented in music instruments, not singing, even song writing is juz so so.
- very commersial. this is very pathetic... this is what make r chinese music industry in low quality. so ironic that his album still the best selling. chinese taste r so bad. so pathetic.
- some song r really long lasting but some are totally forgoten.
- he is chinese educated but cant even write his lyric whereelse david tao & lee hom r english educated n they write all there lyric... hmmm...
Posted by: nskoon83 at August 7, 2006 01:17 PM
i do not understand what is wrong with the commercial musics? why many people here keep criticise on commercial musicians and their muscis.
commercial = popularity
popularity = being widely admired, accepted
being widely admired, accepted = outstanding sales volumn
outstanding sales volumn = bring up economy and music industry
since the commercial musician like jaychow can bring a lot fun to his fans and high profits to himself as well as companies. I think he is in the right direction in his career. The purpose of listening music is just to get touched and fun. For those criticns here saying that " this is very pathetic... this is what make r chinese music industry in low quality. so ironic that his album still the best selling. chinese taste r so bad. so pathetic"
But those people could not be farseeing what actually happening behind, it is real pathetic! commercial musics bring high profits to chinese music industry. I think this is a healthy atmosphere, do you really wanna see one day our music industry full of idealists doing what they think is rite, without concerning the sales volumn? what will happen?
For those people could not understand why jay's music is being widely accepted than the other two. Try go back think of the reasons why. Do you think only you are the one who knows how to listen musics? ain't us?
Keep pointing out jay's negative side without strong supported points. Those are bullshit.
Please do not simply here to say something make people feel that you are childish. And you have no right to saying chinese taste r bad! this makes you looks stupid and ineducated.
Posted by: gamerjjx at September 5, 2006 02:29 PM
hi. writer of this blog
i came to see this page because i thought it would be some sort of fair comparison that ure making between david leehom and jay.
ooh . but no.
its another bias article..just like the ones in the newspaper and ba gua magazines isn't it?
is the aim of this writing just to critisize jay and his music? because if it is..please dont make it sound like as if ure doing this in a FAIR way cos obviousely ure NOT..
i'm not depressing ANY of the fans here..I myself like DAVID LEEHom AND JAY myself.
u just didn't have to put your title like this ' 陶喆 王力宏 周杰倫之全方位比較'
and pretend its fair. cos a bonker noes its not.
Posted by: MRS CHOU at October 16, 2006 10:36 PM